PLC Programming Preference Survey: Insights & User Comments | Automation.com

PLC Programming Preference Survey: Insights & User Comments

PLC Programming Preference Survey: Insights & User Comments

By Bill Lydon, Contributing Editor, Automation.com

The PLCopen organization and Automation.com conducted a joint survey of PLC programming preferences.  The majority of over 200 responses from PLC users were from North America and Europe. Here are some of the results to inform you of current trends in PLC programming and users thoughts on vendors.

Survey Results

In the other category C and C++ programming was a prominent method.  Many IEC 61131-3 programming environments provide the ability to create function blocks written in C and C++.

Process Control

One of the growing trends in PLC usage is a range of process control applications and this is reflected in the responses.   Over 75% of respondents use PLCs in process control applications.

 

Programming Proficiency

Supplier Software

Respondents were asked how they believe suppliers are meeting their needs in different areas.  Respondents provided a number of thoughts and comments.

Any comments or thoughts on how PLC suppliers might better meet your programming software needs?

Portability

  • Multi-vendor portability with PLCopen XML might not be available or does not work always properly. It is good that vendors are nowadays providing open scripting interfaces for the programming environments. With those environments, code conversions and automatic operations are easy to made.
  • Cross platform compatibility
  • PLC suppliers/developers all hate their competitors. The idea that I can plug an ethernet cable from a ControlLogix PLC to a S7-400 and have them communicate directly is a fantasy.
  • Greater cross portability of already developed code.

OPC UA

  • Adopt full OPC UA support! The possibilities are fantastic, but the implementation is still lacking.
  • The user should be able to define its own information model and adopt to other standard models (i.e. packML and many others).
  • PLCopen model should fully take advantage of the OOP capability in structured text. So that communicating on OPC UA should simply give you an interface that you can point on an instance in the OPC UA network and treat as if it was an object (FB) inside your program. We have finally an object oriented communication architecture and object oriented programming! But we still need to use a state machine to do method calls. Why??"

Reliability

  • IDE's not crashing or blue screening the OS
  • Reliability issues occur with modern integrated programming environments. Every vendor is too busy integrating their programming environments into one tool and implementing new fancy features while reliability and usability issues cause costly time loss for end users.

Programming Features

  • Auto complete tag names while typing in ST
  • Meaningful error messages
  • Documentation that is easily accessible and searchable
  • Software developers responsive to customers and their own support technicians.
  • Allow for complex programming to be embedded within a ladder programming framework.
  • Improve ladder instructions, to remove the need for complex training.
  • Automatic code generation from SFC charts.
  • Open system like C/java
  • Compilation of text files is the way of C-type programing tools. There are simple possibilities of versioning, archiving, managing, using libraries and conversion to another compiler / version / language.
  • Standard templates for PLC logic and standard boiler plates for HMI.
  • Adopt modern programming techniques. The suppliers should have better knowledge and integration of source code control (Git), unit testing etc.  Note: Git is a distributed version-control system for tracking changes in source code during software development. It is designed for coordinating work among programmers, but it can be used to track changes in any set of files.
     

PLCopen & OPC UA Collaboration

Industry 4.0 & Digitalization is driving towards modern IoT methods and court of this is semantic information models.  The industrial automation industry has been behind in creating open semantic models and this is why PLCopen and the OPC Foundation created a joint working group to address these needs.  Results include a standard OPC UA Information Model for IEC 61131-3 and PLCopen OPC UA Information Model for IEC 61131-3

OPC UA PLCopen Collaboration Overview Video

About PLCopen

PLCopen is an independent worldwide organization providing efficiency in industrial automation based on the needs of users. It was founded in 1992 and has its headquarters in The Netherlands with supporting offices in the USA, Japan, China, and Korea.

PLCopen and its members have concentrated on technical specifications around the IEC 61131-3 standard in order to reduce costs in industrial engineering. This resulted for example in standardized libraries for different application fields, harmonized language conformity levels, engineering interfaces for exchange, and transparent communication. Experts of the PLCopen members are organized in various technical committees and together with end users define such open standards.

PLCopen is a vendor and product independent worldwide association for topics related to industrial control programming. PLCopen consistently improves efficiency.

Because of the fruitful cooperation with our members, anyone can benefit from knowledge, support and create solutions in all fields of automation.

Read more about PLCopen and on how to become a member

Did you Enjoy this Article?

Check out our free e-newsletters
to read more great articles.

Subscribe Now

MORE ARTICLES

  • The Push and Pull of Composite Manufacturing 
    The Push and Pull of Composite Manufacturing

    By Robert Glass, Exel Composites
    From window and door manufacturers to the professional tree surgeon, weighing up material options usually comes...

  • Augmented Intelligence 
    Augmented Intelligence

    By Mark Howard, EU Automation
    Augmented intelligence is one of the few technologies named on the Gartner Hype Cycle for Emerging Technologies,...

  • Robots or Cobots: Which to Choose? 
    Robots or Cobots: Which to Choose?

    By Jonathan Wilkins, EU Automation
    Today’s plant managers are faced with a dearth of automation technologies but it’s not always obvious what...

  • A Closer Look at Composites 
    A Closer Look at Composites

    By Robert Glass, Exel Composites
    Composites have transformed the technologies of many industries —although the materials used to manufacture...

  • How AI is Disrupting the Oil and Gas Industry 
    How AI is Disrupting the Oil and Gas Industry

    By Ripal Vyas, Softweb Solutions
    The arrival of new technologies like artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) is transforming the...

VIEW ALL

RELATED